Skip to main content

case analysis of rattan singh vs. state of punjab

 Rattan Singh vs. State of Punjab (1979) SCC (4) 713

INTRODUCTION:

Petitioner: Rattan Singh

Respondent: State of Punjab 

Bench: Krishna Iyer, V.R. 

             Shingal, P.N. 

Citation: 1. 1980 AIR 84

                2. 1980 SCR (1) 846

                3. 1979 SCC (4) 719

In this case Mr. Rattan Singh, a driver, of heavy automobiles was sentenced to two years of imprisonment under section 304A of IPC for Rash and Negligent Driving for killing a scooterist by his rash and negligent driving. 

Facts of the case:


  1. The law under section 304A and under the rubric of negligence must have regard to the fatal frequency of rash driving of heavy duty vehicles and of speeding menace.

  2. Whether the sentence was excessive. 

  3. The petitioner appealed that someone else was responsible for the accident, but the request was rejected and is proven guilty. 

  4. Rashness and negligence are relative concepts, not absolute abstractions. 

  5. Here, role of  “res ispa loquitor” with care applies, it means that “the things speaks for itself”


Verdict of the case:


It was held that he is punishable for imprisonment of two years under section 304A of IPC.

Rashness and negligence are the relative concepts, not absolute abstractions. When a life has been lost and the circumstances of driving are harsh, no compassion can be shown. 

  • Sentencing must have a policy of correction. When the punishment is for driving offence, the state should attach a course for better driving together with sense of responsibility especially in the case of men in poor families, the state may consider occasional parole and reformatory course. 

  • Victim reparation is still the vanishing point of criminal law. The victims of the crime, and the distress of the prisoner, do not attract the attention of the law. The deficiency in the system must be rectified by the legislature. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

VIRTUAL INTERNSHIP PROGRAMME BY LEXIS AND COMPANY

  VIRTUAL INTERNSHIP PROGRAMME BY LEXIS AND COMPANY. VIRTUAL INTERNSHIP PROGRAMME BY LEXIS AND COMPANY. (PLEASE READ THE DETAILS CAREFULLY BEFORE APPLYING). KINDLY READ THE FULL DETAILS AND DESCRIPTION VERY CAREFULLY BEFORE APPLYING OR DURING FILLING UP THE REGISTRATION FORM, SO THAT YOU AVOID ASKING UNWANTED QUESTION FOR WHICH THE DETAILS ARE ALREADY GIVEN IN THE FORM. KINDLY SEND THE FOLLOWING DETAILS IN THE GROUP OR DM AFTER FILING THE REGISTRATION FORM OR IN CASE YOU ARE NOT ABLE TO JOIN THE GROUP THEN SEND IT ON OUR OFFICIAL WHATS APP NUMBER IN DM: NAME: PREFERRED MONTH OF INTERNSHIP: PREFERRED DATE FROM WHICH YOU WANT TO START THE INTERNSHIP: PREFERRED MODULE IN WHICH YOU WANT TO JOIN AS SELECTED BY YOU: LAC-VIP – An initiative of Lexis and Company At LAC our motto is to strive for legal excellence, by assuring (instead of making sure) that all the demands of our clients are fulfilled as per their convenience and that they leave fully satisfied from the services we provide. At Le

URGENT HIRING FOR JUNIOR ASSOCIATE - LEGAL (LEVEL - 1)

  Junior Associates - Legal (LEVEL - 1) --- PLEASE READ THE COMPLETE JOB DESCRIPTION BEFORE APPLYING ---   Urgent Hiring for: LAW STUDENTS. Position: Junior Associates - Legal (LEVEL - 1) Department: Legal. Firm Name: LEXIS AND COMPANY – LAW FIRM. Location: Janakpuri, New Delhi. CTC: RS 5000/- Per Month. (First three months the associate will be on probation and training, and during this period no salary or stipend will be paid, after 3 months of regular service upon meeting the required number of working days and performance evaluation, the associates will be eligible for this pay band.) Additional Allowance: All official expenses including travelling allowance for official purposes will be paid from the day 1 of the service with the firm.   We are urgently looking for Law Students for the position of Junior Associates - Legal (LEVEL - 1) for our Law Firm in Janakpuri, New Delhi.   Eligibility: Mandatory Qualification: Any Law Students of 3 Years or 5 Years Law/LLB progra

HIRING FOR PHYSICAL INTERNSHIP PROGRAMME (LAC-PIP) AT LEXIS AND COMPANY - LAW FIRM

    WE ARE URGENTLY LOOKING FOR LAW STUDENTS, OR NEWLY ENROLLED ADVOCATES FOR  PHYSICAL INTERNSHIP PROGRAMME  AT OUR LAW FIRM IN JANAKPURI, NEW DELHI. PHYSICAL INTERNSHIP PROGRAMME BY LEXIS AND COMPANY LAW FIRM IS A UNIQUE AND CUSTOMIZED LEGAL TRAINING PROGRAMME FOR LAW STUDENTS AND ADVOCATES WHO WANTS TO BUILD THEIR CAREER IN LITIGATION AS AN INDIVIDUAL PRACTITIONER OR JOIN ANY CORPORATE LAW FIRM. (PLEASE READ THE DETAILS CAREFULLY BEFORE APPLYING).  CANDIDATES WHO ARE READY TO WORK PHYSICALLY AT OUR OFFICE IN JANAKPURI, NEW DELHI, SHOULD ONLY APPLY. CANDIDATE LOOKING FOR ONLINE JOB OR WORK FROM HOME JOB OR FREELANCE JOB OR PART TIME JOB SHOULD APPLY FOR OUR VIRTUAL INTERNSHIP PROGRAMME. QUALIFICATIONS: CANDIDATE WHO ARE EITHER LAW STUDENTS OR NEWLY ENROLLED AS AN ADVOCATE LOOKING TO LEARN AS A BEGINNER SHOULD ONLY APPLY. WORKING DAYS: MONDAY TO SATURDAY, 9:00 AM TO 06:00 PM. (PHYSICAL ONSITE) THIS JOB IS MORE OF A LEARNING OPPORTUNITY ONLY FOR LAW STUDENTS AND NEWLY ENROLLED ADVOCATE